Film Scouts Reviews

"From the Journals of Jean Seberg"

by Kathleen Carroll

Buy this video from
In FROM THE JOURNALS OF JEAN SEBERG director Mark Rappaport reflects on the disappointing career and unhappy life of the ill-fated actress. In short this remarkably perceptive film is no ordinary celebrity profile. For the truth is Seberg never recorded her thoughts in a journal and Rappaport is simply projecting his own thoughts in what amounts to a fictionalized autobiography. In it the director imagines what Seberg might have said about her past if she had been able to do a critical evaluation of her film work and her personal problems.

As Rappaport suggests Seberg was a victim of her times. Actress Mary Beth Hurt subs for Seberg, delivering caustic comments while presiding over a clip show of her work. In the first section of the film Hurt, as Seberg, recalls the event that forever changed the destiny of this small town girl from Iowa.

The event was the nationwide talent search for a 17-year-old to play Saint Joan which Seberg won for no other obvious reason than the fact that she was only 17. The film notes that Barbra Streisand supposedly tried out for the part. "Imagine how different the history of show business would have been if she had got it," says Hurt as the image of Streisand singing "People" while surrounded by flames flashes on the screen.

It was Seberg who ultimately burned at the stake in Otto Preminger's lamentable production of "Saint Joan." The notoriously sadistic Preminger actually set her on fire in his obsessive effort to coax a performance out of her. The critics, however, roasted her for playing a tragic French heroine with a flat Midwestern accent.

Ironically it was Seberg's dewy fresh all-American good looks that eventually captivated French director Jean-Luc Godard who capitalized on those looks in "Breathless." As the film points out Seberg broke "the first rule of film acting" by looking directly at the audience. She is shown staring vacantly at the camera with the wary intensity of a prisoner facing an interrogation.

Her uncanny beauty was still evident but the late Robert Rossen cast Seberg in "Lilith" because she reminded him of "a cheerleader who's cracked up." Seberg was herself on the verge of cracking up at the time. She had become a political activist in the '60's like her two contemporaries, Jane Fonda and Vanessa Redgrave, whose career choices are also examined. But her support of the Black Panther movement made her a target of an FBI witch hunt. Her husband, French novelist Romain Gary, humiliated her by writing a hopelessly pretentious film in which she played a poker-faced nymphomaniac. The film concludes that it was finally all too much for Seberg who committed suicide at the age of 40.

Rappaport also provides a fresh take on film history. Displaying a rare intelligence and a wry wit he offers some astute, tartly funny observations about the mistreatment of women by male directors. "Is it true that the camera steals your soul?," asks Hurt, speaking on Seberg's behalf. In Seberg's case it would appear as if the camera did just that.

Back to 1995 New York Film Festival Reviews

Back to From the Journals of Jean Seberg

Back to the Press Room

Look for Search Tips

Copyright 1994-2008 Film Scouts LLC
Created, produced, and published by Film Scouts LLC
Film Scouts® is a registered trademark of Film Scouts LLC
All rights reserved.

Suggestions? Comments? Fill out our Feedback Form.